Reading practice · B2

Why People Struggle to Save: The Psychology and Design of Household Saving

saving · 706 words · 17 questions · about 20 minutes.

All passages

Reading passage

A

Saving money is one of those resolutions that almost everyone makes and few people keep. Surveys in wealthy countries repeatedly find that a large minority of households could not cover an unexpected bill of a few hundred pounds or dollars without borrowing. In the United States, the Federal Reserve has reported that roughly a third of adults would struggle with a sudden four-hundred-dollar expense. The gap between intention and behaviour has made personal saving a rich field of study for economists and psychologists alike.

B

The traditional economic view assumes that people save rationally, weighing current pleasures against future needs and smoothing their consumption across a lifetime. In this model, low saving is simply a choice reflecting personal preference or tight budgets. Yet the persistence of regret suggests otherwise: most non-savers say they wish they saved more, which indicates that something other than calm calculation is at work.

C

Behavioural research points to present bias, the tendency to give immediate rewards far more weight than future ones. A dinner out tonight feels real and vivid, whereas retirement is abstract and distant, so the dinner usually wins. This bias helps explain why saving rates often rise in times of crisis, when the future suddenly feels closer. During the first year of the pandemic, for example, household saving rates in several countries doubled or tripled, partly because shops and travel were closed and partly because uncertainty made the future feel urgent.

D

Income matters, of course, but it is not the whole story. Studies comparing households at similar income levels find striking differences in saving behaviour, driven by habit, culture and even language. Some economists have noted that languages with a strong future tense, which force speakers to mark the future grammatically, are associated with lower saving rates, perhaps because the future feels more separate from the present. Family upbringing leaves a mark as well. Adults whose parents discussed money openly tend to save more confidently than those raised in households where finances were never mentioned. Researchers also find that simply watching a parent put coins into a jar can normalise the habit for children decades later.

E

Institutions also shape outcomes. Countries with automatic enrolment into workplace pension schemes, such as the United Kingdom since 2012, have seen participation rates climb above eighty per cent, far higher than under voluntary systems. The lesson is that defaults are powerful: when saving happens unless you act, most people save; when saving requires you to act, most people postpone.

F

Interest rates play a complicated role. Low rates reduce the reward for saving in theory, yet the years of near-zero rates after 2008 did not destroy the saving habit everywhere. In Germany and the Netherlands, households kept saving steadily despite minimal returns, partly out of cultural prudence and partly because they feared future tax rises or pension shortfalls. Economists call this precautionary saving, and it tends to rise when people feel insecure about jobs or state support.

G

Technology has introduced new tools. Banking apps now round up purchases and sweep the spare change into savings pots, turning saving into a series of painless micro-decisions. Some apps send cheerful notifications when balances grow, borrowing techniques from games and social media. Early evidence suggests these nudges raise balances modestly, especially among younger users who rarely visit bank branches.

H

Critics warn that an exclusive focus on individual behaviour lets governments and employers off the hook. Stagnant wages, expensive housing and insecure gig work leave many households with nothing left to save, whatever their psychological discipline. In several large cities, rent alone consumes more than forty per cent of median income, a burden that no budgeting app can fix. Rising energy and food prices hit savers twice, first by shrinking the spare cash available each month and then by eroding the real value of whatever has been put aside. For the lowest earners, even a small emergency can trigger a spiral of overdrafts and high-interest loans.

I

The realistic conclusion, researchers say, is that saving is partly a matter of willpower and partly a matter of design. Systems that make saving automatic, visible and slightly rewarding help ordinary people act on their best intentions. Waiting for discipline alone to do the job, the evidence suggests, means waiting a long time.

Questions

Question 1What does the passage say about the traditional economic view of saving?

Question 2Why did household saving rates rise sharply during the first year of the pandemic?

Question 3What effect did automatic enrolment have on workplace pension participation in the United Kingdom?

Question 4According to the passage, why did German and Dutch households keep saving despite near-zero interest rates?

Question 5What do critics say about focusing only on individual behaviour to explain low saving?

Question 6Languages that force speakers to mark the future grammatically are linked to higher saving rates.

Question 7Saving apps have raised balances mainly among older customers.

Question 8The Federal Reserve adjusts its interest rates specifically to encourage household saving.

Question 9Households at the same income level can save very differently from one another.

Question 10Behavioural researchers blame ______, which makes immediate rewards feel more important than future ones.

Write NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS from the passage.

Question 11Economists call saving that rises when people feel insecure about jobs or state support ______ saving.

Write NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS from the passage.

Question 12Banking apps round up purchases and sweep the ______ into savings pots.

Write NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS from the passage.

Question 13In several large cities, rent alone consumes more than forty per cent of ______ income.

Write NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS from the passage.

Question 14a reference to an official report on households unable to cover a sudden expense

Which paragraph contains this information?

Question 15an example of how automatic defaults raised participation in a workplace scheme

Which paragraph contains this information?

Question 16a mention of app design features borrowed from games and social media

Which paragraph contains this information?

Question 17a reference to the share of income that rent consumes in some large cities

Which paragraph contains this information?